The Crow’s Nest Sean MacPhearson does seaside eatery at Montauk inn

96 top rated

  • The Crow’s Nest

  • 4 Old West Lake Dr. Montauk, NY 11954 (631) 668-2077
Book Now website
reviewed by
Ann Vine Editorial Review Author

  • The Scene:

    Arriving to the Montauk scene is Sean MacPhearson, owner of the Bowery Hotel in NY and LA’s Il Covo, who offers a pedigree restaurant and on-site inn along a waterfront location near the center of town. A quintessential beach eatery offers indoor-outdoor environment of signature seaside elements that blend urban design and Macphearson’s iconic touch of eclectic. The crowd offers a mix of Hampton second homeowners that complain about the long drive with burgeoning artists and bohemian summer scene that’s emerged in recent years as Montauk has exploded in popularity. 

  • cuisine
  • price
  • payment options
    Visa, MasterCard, American Express
  • hours
    11am-late, daily (mid-May-Sept.)
  • table to get
    Terrace
  • special features
    Hip Clientele, Market Fresh, Locally Sourced

  • The Food:

    A dinner-only dining room to open daily through the summer offer a handwritten menu of local produce includes kale salads with fennel, grilled artichoke with saffron aiolo and roasted beets with fresh yogurt. Main courses tout local seafood like fluke, skate and halibut as well as organic rib eye and heirloom tomato pasta that complete one of Montauk’s chicest summer hotel scenes.

  • Last Word

    Owner of the Bowery Hotel does Montuak Inn with camper-chic style and it-restaurant. The hotel and restaurant got off to a slow-start, but expect things to rev to a full throttle till the end of summer.

Related Reviews

  • 92

    Blue Parrot

    Mexican cafe returns more Bahama than Texas

    Showbiz investors restore Hampton cantina

    Editorial: Ann Vine

    read the review
  • 93

    OSO

    Cozy inn food for casual dinners in Southampton

    Snazzy eatery enlivens Southampton Inn

    Editorial: Ann Vine

    read the review
  • 97

    Sienna Restaurant

    T-Bar owner does riviera dining scene in East Hampton

    NYC hotspot does summertime pop-up with weekend Pink Elephant

    Editorial: Ann Vine

    read the review